Leading a team is an incredible responsibility. You’re not only tasked with achieving goals, but also with fostering a positive and productive environment for your employees. This includes supporting their mental health, which can significantly impact their well-being and work performance. 

But how do you identify a potential mental health concern and navigate that conversation? Here, we’ll explore a three-step process to help you effectively address mental health as a leader, fostering a workplace culture that prioritizes well-being alongside success. 

Step 1: Develop a Baseline and Monitor Employee Performance 

Before spotting deviations, you need a solid understanding of your team’s baseline performance. This involves regularly monitoring several key factors: 

• Workload: Are employees consistently overloaded? Look for signs of missed deadlines, decreased quality of work, or frequent requests for extensions. 

• Vacation and Time Off: Are employees utilizing their allocated vacation time? Are they taking regular sick days? Unusual patterns might indicate underlying issues. 

• Hours and Overtime: Watch for excessive overtime, which can lead to burnout. 

• Absence and Sick Time: A sudden increase in sick leave or unexplained absences could be a red flag. 

What to Implement: 

• Regularly Scheduled 1:1 Meetings: Establish regular one-on-one meetings with each team member. Go beyond just work tasks. Ask how they’re doing, what challenges they’re facing, and what their workload feels like. Use this time to build rapport and get to know their baseline behavior and performance. 

By creating these consistent touchpoints, you’ll be better equipped to identify any noticeable changes in the future, potentially signaling a mental health concern. 

Step 2: Have the Conversation 

If you suspect someone on your team might be struggling with a mental health issue, it’s vital to have a supportive conversation. Here’s how to approach it effectively: 

Gather reinforcements: Consider looping in a higher-level leader or HR representative for support before the conversation. Their expertise can be invaluable in navigating the situation and ensuring company resources are utilized correctly. 

Support and Discuss Concerns: Initiate the conversation by expressing your concern for the employee’s well-being. Frame it around performance changes you’ve observed and suggest ways you can support them. 

Referral to a Professional Provider: When appropriate, present options for seeking professional help. This can be: 

• Voluntary: Offer resources like Employee Assistance Programs (EAP) and mental health hotlines. Encourage the employee to seek support if they feel it would be beneficial. 

• Mandatory: In more serious cases, if performance significantly deteriorates or safety is a concern, you might need to suggest mandatory professional support. This may be combined with a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) to address specific concerns. 

• Disciplinary Action: Remember, mental health issues can often qualify as a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). This requires reasonable accommodations to be made. However, severe or persistent disruptive behavior could warrant disciplinary action. 

Language and Temperament: 

• Stay Calm: Maintain a calm and understanding demeanor throughout the conversation. 

• Avoid Blame Language: Focus on the issue, not the person. Instead of saying “You’ve been missing deadlines,” say “I’ve noticed you haven’t met your last few deadlines. Is there anything going on that I can help with?” 

• Listen Actively: Give the employee your full attention and allow them to express their concerns openly. 

• Be Real: Acknowledge the challenges of mental health and express your willingness to help. 

• Work on a Plan Together: Discuss ways you can support the employee at work, like adjusting deadlines, delegating tasks, or providing additional resources. 

Step 3: Put in the Groundwork for a Better Tomorrow 

Building a supportive workplace culture goes beyond addressing individual concerns. Here are ways to create a long-term environment that prioritizes mental well-being: 

• Build Trust and Be Vulnerable: Be transparent and open with your team. Share your own struggles and encourage others to do the same. This fosters a culture of trust and understanding. 

• Model Healthy Behavior: Set a good example by practicing healthy work-life balance, taking breaks, and encouraging your team to do the same. 

• Embrace Flexibility: Recognize that one-size-fits-all approaches rarely work. Be open to flexible work arrangements and schedules when possible. 

• Clarity and Alignment: Clearly communicate company goals and individual priorities. This reduces stress and fosters a sense of purpose. 

• Overcommunicate: Don’t assume your team knows everything. Keep them informed about changes and decisions that might impact their work. 

• Consistency: Be reliable and consistent in your leadership style. This creates a sense of security and predictability. 

• Invest in Training: Educate yourself and your team on mental health awareness. This can help break down stigma and empower employees to seek help if needed. 

• Modify Policies and Practices: Review and revise policies with mental health in mind. Consider offering mental health days or generous sick leave provisions. 

• Measure and Adjust: Track the impact of your efforts. Utilize anonymous surveys to assess employee well-being and adapt your approach based on feedback. 

• Advocate for Resources: Champion a culture that prioritizes mental health. Be vocal about the need for resources and advocate for their inclusion in your benefits package. 

• Proactive Safe Space: Create a safe and supportive environment. Let your team know your door is always open and encourage open communication. 

• Benefits and Integration: Explore ways to integrate mental health resources into your benefits package. This could include employee assistance programs, access to therapists, or reimbursement for mental health services. 

• Pulse Surveys and Check-Ins: Regularly check in with your team through pulse surveys or informal chats. This allows them to share concerns before they escalate. 

• Schedule and Keep Meetings: Prioritize your one-on-one meetings and stick to the schedule. This shows your team that their well-being is truly important. 

• Provide Sustainable Resources: Don’t let mental health initiatives be a passing fad. Ensure resources and support systems are available and sustainable in the long run. 

• Transparency is Key: Be as transparent as possible about company policies and procedures. This reduces anxiety and fosters trust. 

• The Bigger Picture: Help your employees understand how their work contributes to the bigger picture. This fosters a sense of purpose and motivation. 

• Focus on Mental Health Importance: Normalize conversations about mental health. Organize workshops or talks to raise awareness and address any stigma. 

• Building Resiliency: Encourage healthy coping mechanisms and stress management techniques. This empowers your team to navigate challenges effectively. 

• Enable Performance, not Micromanage: Set clear expectations but trust your team to deliver results. Micromanaging can be detrimental to mental well-being. 

• Motivate for Happiness: Promote positive reinforcement and recognize achievements. Foster a work environment where happiness is valued alongside productivity. 

• Boundaries are Essential: Set clear boundaries for work communication and after-hours expectations. This helps maintain a healthy work-life balance. 

• Simplify and Focus: Focus on lean principles and avoid overwhelming your team with complex processes. Keep things simple and streamlined. 

By implementing these steps, you can build a supportive workplace culture that fosters mental well-being. It’s a continuous process, but the positive impact on your team and your organization will be well worth the effort. Remember, happy and healthy employees are more productive, engaged, and committed to achieving success. Let’s prioritize mental well-being and create a future where work is not just productive, but also supportive and enriching. 

The MP team is wired for HR, which includes supporting your team’s mental health. By upgrading to MP’s powerful HCM platform and proactive, practical HR consulting strategy, we’ll ensure that your organization is in compliance, your employees are performing well and satisfied, and your business is optimized for success. Talk to an MP expert today to learn more.  

For more tips on creating a workplace that supports positive mental health, read our latest blogs here.  

Make sure to subscribe to MP’s blog and stay on top of the most up-to-date news and trends in the business realm.