If your I-9 process hasn’t evolved to accommodate remote work, your organization is vulnerable. 

In 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) will resume audits in full. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) is conducting unannounced worksite inspections. And hybrid onboarding workflows are creating serious compliance blind spots for employers—especially those without a dedicated audit process in place. 

The risk is real—but fixable. 

This article outlines the most common errors we’re seeing, how enforcement has shifted, and the simple steps HR leaders can take now to avoid costly penalties. 

The I-9 Enforcement Landscape in 2025 

ICE has resumed aggressive enforcement following a lull during the pandemic. According to USCIS guidance: 

• Employers must complete Section 1 on or before the first day of employment, and 

• Section 2 must be completed within 3 business days after the start date. 

• In most cases, employers must physically examine documentation, unless they are part of the DHS Alternative Procedure for remote I-9 reviews. 

• Minor paperwork errors can lead to civil penalties ranging from $272 to $2,701 per form under the latest fine schedule. 

📚 USCIS Source: I-9 Central – Compliance Requirements 

How Remote and Hybrid Work Have Complicated I-9s 

Hybrid onboarding and decentralized HR teams often mean: 

• Delays in completing Section 2 

• Untrained remote agents reviewing documents 

• Missing audit trails or document expiration tracking 

• Inconsistent reverification across departments 

ICE is increasingly flagging employers who do not maintain standardized, documented I-9 procedures across all locations—including remote workers. 

Most Common Remote I-9 Compliance Errors 

1. Failure to complete Section 2 on time 

2. Improper document combinations (List A vs. List B + C) 

3. Missing or unsigned employer attestation 

4. No clear record of who reviewed documents for remote employees 

5. No reverification tracking for work authorization expiration dates 

6. Incorrect use of the DHS Alternative Procedure 

2025 I-9 Compliance Checklist (Audit-Ready Version) 

Use this checklist to assess where your team stands—and where to focus immediately: 

PRE-HIRE 

• Recruiters and hiring managers are trained on what questions are compliant during interviews 

• No questions about citizenship or work authorization are asked before making a conditional offer 

NEW HIRE I-9 COMPLETION 

• Section 1 is completed on or before the first day of employment 

• Section 2 is completed within 3 business days 

• Employer or authorized agent signs and dates Section 2 

• Copies of supporting documents (if required by policy) are stored securely 

REMOTE WORKERS 

• Authorized representative is trained and designated in writing 

• Employer documents name/contact info of the verifier 

• Only uses physical inspection unless enrolled in DHS Alternative Procedure (source) 

REVERIFICATION & REHIRES 

• Expiring work authorizations are tracked, and reverification is completed before expiration 

• Rehires within 3 years use the original I-9 when possible 

• Section 3 completed correctly for reverifications 

STORAGE & AUDIT 

• I-9s stored for 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later 

• Stored separately from personnel files 

• Annual internal audits are conducted 

• Site visit protocol in place for ICE/USCIS interactions 

Final Thought: Get Ahead or Get Audited 

Increased audits, decentralized hiring, and shifting remote policies make I-9 compliance a top HR risk in 2025. Most violations are preventable—but only if your team is proactive, trained, and audit-ready. 

How MP Can Help 

MP partners with HR teams to strengthen compliance from the inside out. Whether you’re onboarding remote employees, reviewing expired work authorizations, or just unsure where your I-9s stand, we help you assess risk and tighten your process. 

We’re not here to replace your team; we’re here to support it. 
Let’s build confidence into your compliance. 

Make sure to subscribe to MP’s blog and stay on top of the most up-to-date news and trends in the business realm.